番茄影院

Skip to main content

Your web browser is out of date. Please update it for greater security, speed and the best experience on this site.

IOP Trusted Reviewer Status

IOP Trusted Reviewer certification is designed to recognise the very best peer reviewers in the physical sciences. It will give you the recognition you deserve and highlights the important work of our reviewers.

What does an excellent review look like?

A top-rated five-star review meets the following criteria:

  • Very thorough, covering all sections of the manuscript
  • Relevant to the subject of the manuscript and the broader field
  • Includes a comparison with existing literature
  • Report is returned in a timely manner
  • Recommendation is clearly justified and in line with the journal鈥檚 editorial standards

Overall, a five-star review is exceptionally detailed and add valuable insight when informing the Editor鈥檚 decision.

Watch our video about IOP Trusted Reviewer status

For guidance on how to write an excellent report, including example reviews, see .